Reviews

When you want impeccable service and delicious food - this is your restaurant. General Manager Jim
When you want impeccable service and delicious food - this is your restaurant. General Manager Jim Nethercott is always on hand to make sure you feel at home the minute you step inside in the door. The staff is courteous, attentive and superb! If you love ITALIAN food you’ll love this gem - the food is amazing! ... Check it out with ... read more
Amy Pauszek via facebook.com - Aug 18, 2018
Italian Food Made From Scratch
This may be the best Italian restaurant in Central Indiana! Seven of us dined here and each had a different dish. We all loved our food! Everything from the bread to the cannoli was fresh, including the pasta. The place was packed for a Wednesday...More ... read more
1776SJA via tripadvisor.com - Aug 15, 2018
Phenomenal place with authentic italian food, the Italian wedding soup is great and I can't stay away from the veal the other day they had a great lamb special, super tender nice selection of wines the atmosphere is where it's at though, inside the house is cozy but outside is such a fun place to be, and the bar house is just as c ... read more
Audrey Nicole Cross via google.com - Aug 13, 2018
Good Stuff ... read more
Sean Yau via google.com - Aug 10, 2018
Celebrated our 43rd anniversary there tonight...good wine and food! Nice atmosphere out on the patio.
Katherine Sarver via google.com - Aug 10, 2018
Incredible food and atmosphere!
Suzy Pero via google.com - Aug 10, 2018
Excellent food and atmosphere
I am often in the Westfield area but had never heard of this place or this little strip of street with quaint restaurants. It was a beautiful night to sit outside but the inside looked nice as well. Since we were with a large group,...More ... read more
JHR6829 via tripadvisor.com - Aug 6, 2018
Wonderful food in a delightfully charming setting. This is the kind of place that you cannot tire o
Wonderful food in a delightfully charming setting. This is the kind of place that you cannot tire of . It’s a keeper! ... read more
Lisa Ludwig via facebook.com - Aug 6, 2018
Service, appetizers, dinner, desserts... all excellent. Highly recommend.
Service, appetizers, dinner, desserts... all excellent. Highly recommend.
via facebook.com - Aug 5, 2018
Food was excellent. Sitting on the back patio is a nice setting. Service was very good. Only complaints would be that the dishes weren't exactly the cleanest I've seen and a bolognese dish is listed on their website, but for whatever reason they no longer serve it.
James Inman via google.com - Aug 1, 2018
Great italian in Westfield
My husband and I had an impromptu date night during the week. The service and food were very good! I had the sausage orecchiette and my husband the carbonara.
JScheffs via tripadvisor.com - Jul 31, 2018
Spectacular food, great ambiance 7/28
I was introduced to this restaurant by friends, and disastrously broke my diet this evening. Every mouthful was exquisite. I had the carbonara, and though it took a few bites to tune in to the subtle flavors, from then on I was in heaven. The...More ... read more
Whiskey R via tripadvisor.com - Jul 28, 2018
WAS Our Go To Place.....
Love the ambiance and the servers and will go back, but food quality is declining and man "greeting" customers is rude! Avoid the seafood, inconsistent quality, sometimes strong. And an Italian restaurant that serves overcooked and underwhelming meat balls?!? Do sit in the garage or...More ... read more
indydigger via tripadvisor.com - Jul 23, 2018
Currently our GO TO place
Shrimp Scampi very good. Carbanara was the best, perfectly prepared. And, the service was also above average...not overbearing. A little drive north of Indianapolis, but well worth it. Recommend getting reservations.
gold-vintner via tripadvisor.com - Jul 17, 2018
Wine = good. Food = good. Best Italian sausage I've ever had!
Wine = good. Food = good. Best Italian sausage I've ever had!
Sharon Saarela via facebook.com - Jul 13, 2018
Ambiance was perfect and there food is delicious, good services. I loved it, definitely recommend to anyone who likes sea food. You will not be disappointed!
Delaney Rose via google.com - Jul 12, 2018
Best Italian food in town!
We have eaten here twice and been thoroughly pleased. Wonderful food!! The service is great, too! The Italian House is located in a former house. Just an overall enchanting experience!
Candy S via tripadvisor.com - Jul 11, 2018
Great food!
Service was superb and food quality was fabulous! Just a 1.4 miles east of the world famous Jewelry Gallery.
Jason H via tripadvisor.com - Jul 9, 2018
Second Visit Not as Good as the First
This was our second visit to The Italian House on Park. While our first was quite good, this time we were not impressed. Our waitress was rather inattentive. She would approach the table and when we were talking she would just walk away. The real...More ... read more
Cathy K via tripadvisor.com - Jul 9, 2018
Awesome!
Love this place, the food, the atmosphere and the Manhattan drinks! Nice service, limited parking. Best to reserve a table.
Rachel K via tripadvisor.com - Jul 9, 2018
Ordered the Chicken Picatta on angel hair pasta 👌🏻If you enjoy red wine, “Conundrum” was tasty and
Ordered the Chicken Picatta on angel hair pasta 👌🏻 If you enjoy red wine, “Conundrum” was tasty and a good deal. We were plesently surprised it was also a 1litre bottle 👍🏻Bonus great service too ... read more
Deborah Santander via facebook.com - Jul 8, 2018
The food and atmosphere were good. Hostess was rude. Wait staff extremely slow. If you have lots of rime and are older it's a fit. Otherwise avoid the pkace.
Jen P via google.com - Jul 6, 2018
Just phenomenal! All of it. Food, service and ambience.
Dune Crane via google.com - Jul 6, 2018
The atmosphere and food are amazing! So glad we found a new spot.
The atmosphere and food are amazing! So glad we found a new spot. ... read more
Liz Mendenhall via facebook.com - Jul 5, 2018
We had a great meal, and the service was excellent. Can't wait to go back.
Michael Malandrakis via google.com - Jul 3, 2018
Great Experience ... read more
Sherman Toller via google.com - Jun 28, 2018
Great outdoor dining area
The food was excellent and the staff was very prompt and courteous. Great outdoor patio for dining and there is an outdoor bar area as well. Will visit again.
aatask via tripadvisor.com - Jun 24, 2018
Nice place great food and service
Wife and I had a very nice dinner there. We had a reservation on Saturday night and were seated promptly. The server was cordial and helpful. The food was absolutely great. It was our first time there but plan on going back some time soon ... read more
Mike M via tripadvisor.com - Jun 24, 2018
A unique dining experience
This was recommended by friends while we visited in June and we enjoyed it a great deal. We dined with 2 other couples and found the atmosphere perfect for conversation and dining. Prices were right in line with what we expected and the service was...More ... read more
Randy W via tripadvisor.com - Jun 24, 2018
Ambiance-Great! Food-Great! Service-Great! Our second visit! We will be back soon!
Julie Cross via google.com - Jun 24, 2018
Overall a pretty good experience. Maybe more like 4.5 stars. They have a good variety on the menu. Everyone enjoyed their food and drinks. We loved the outdoor seating area. Very relaxing. The service was a bit slow, but with the music and great weather we didn't mind. Probably the only reason I'm not giving it 5 stars is that there ... read more
Alex Andersen via google.com - Jun 21, 2018
Great Italian food
Made a reservation for six but had thirteen when we arrived. The folks there handled it with ease and we all were seated immediately. The place appeared to be an home at sometime and was told by someone with us that the city had rezoned...More ... read more
William J via tripadvisor.com - Jun 19, 2018
Great casual atmosphere and fantastic food
Great casual atmosphere and fantastic food. Was lucky to be able to walk in and be seated, would recommend advance reservation. Food is fresh and menu is diverse.
chrisrops via tripadvisor.com - Jun 19, 2018
Amazing in every way...calamari, scallops, Italian margarita...my faves!
renee selvio via google.com - Jun 18, 2018
Fantastic... My husband and I went there for dinner. I ordered the sea scallops with mushroom risotto and it was cooked perfectly. My husband ordered the ribeye and he said it was the best that he has had in a long time. We will definitely be going back.
Kellie Coffey via google.com - Jun 16, 2018
Food was great and service was excellent. Only three stars because the portions are scant. I got the 'special'. The portion was half that of my companions meal and twice the cost. More than $45 for about 4 ounces of food. I went home and had dinner.
Lou Magyar via google.com - Jun 12, 2018
Beautiful patio and great food!
Jillian Menard via google.com - Jun 7, 2018
Great food, great wine, great atmosphere! Loved the outdoor area! Great for a date night or just a
Great food, great wine, great atmosphere! Loved the outdoor area! Great for a date night or just a laid back drink with friends.
Holly Archbold Gentry via facebook.com - Jun 7, 2018
Fantastic food and service ... read more
Carl Baker via google.com - Jun 6, 2018
This is an amazing date night restaurant with some really great atmosphere. Everything I have ordered has been amazing and we always look forward to stopping in.
Zachary Webster via google.com - Jun 4, 2018
Good food and atmosphere ... read more
Micah Songer via google.com - Jun 2, 2018
Lots of positives
We were a party of 6. Service was quite good. On of our party received his lasagna and the plate was more warm than the food. The waitress corrected the problem to his satisfaction with a replacement dinner (they did not take his plate to...More ... read more
gold-vintner via tripadvisor.com - May 30, 2018
This is a nice, small restaurant with lots of personality. Great wine selection and outstanding food. The service was attentive, but not hovering.
Liz Hlebasko via google.com - May 26, 2018
Ordered the sausage orrchiette and it was fantastic. Had a bit of spice to it, but overall a great dish. It’s always great to get rewarded for getting something a little more adventurous. I wish we had been able to sit out on the patio, but alas, next time. I would definitely head back over here on my next trip through town.
Brian Baldwin via google.com - May 23, 2018
Great food!
Erica R. Diebold via google.com - May 22, 2018
Just awesome ... read more
Matt Lamb via google.com - May 19, 2018
Our server Amy was great as well as the food!
Kim Troyer via google.com - May 19, 2018
dinner with relatives
We had a great dinner with excellent wines. The black bean soup and calamari were great starters. A shrimp special was enjoyed by several, but I had veal picatta which was very good as was the pasta. It was 1/2 price wine night and the...More ... read more
Bob S via tripadvisor.com - May 16, 2018
Such a beautiful atmosphere and wonderful food! It’s a hidden gem and a must visit for all those in Westfield. If visiting on a warmer day, you must sit on the porch or patio.
Taylor Teppen via google.com - May 14, 2018
Great local place
Weather was nice so we were able to sit outside. Beautiful setting, and when Midland trail completed, will be able to,people watch. Excellent service. Wife had penne and I had chicken parmigiana. Both well prepared and tasty. Entrees are not too large and are priced...More ... read more
MK1861 via tripadvisor.com - May 6, 2018
Great Food and Atmosphere!!
Made reservations for 6p. Weather was perfect, we were seated on the back porch overlooking the patio. Great, relaxing scenery. Service by Robin was great. She knew her wines and suggested a white wine that perfectly complimented the Sea Scallops entree. We started with the...More ... read more
Wssloman via tripadvisor.com - May 6, 2018
Great food!
Eric Diebold via google.com - Apr 30, 2018
One of the best meals I've had in the last year , including comparing it to Ruth Chris' or St Elmo's. The setting and ambiance was so simple but very relaxing. Loved the garage bar area, and can't wait to go back!! True hidden gem.
Joel Mcwaters via google.com - Apr 29, 2018
Wonderful dining...
We stopped in for an evening meal and had a wonderful dining experience. The former residence has evolved into a cozy and comfortable eatery. Our server, Aimee, was friendly and attentive. The opening bruschetta and baked potato soup provided a tasty beginning; with the accompanying...More ... read more
RICART75 via tripadvisor.com - Apr 22, 2018
Friendly, lovely staff. Food was amazing-great flavorful dishes, very ample portions, and appealing
Friendly, lovely staff. Food was amazing-great flavorful dishes, very ample portions, and appealing presentation. It was a perfect setting to celebrate a birthday with family!
Sally Sibbitt-Schuler via facebook.com - Apr 21, 2018
Food was VERY good, wait person was excellent. If I had to say anything bad it would be that it’s v
Food was VERY good, wait person was excellent. If I had to say anything bad it would be that it’s very loud. Reservations are the best. Very quaint, will return.
Anita Dungan via facebook.com - Apr 10, 2018
amazingggg
I recently visited here for a business trip, and I already cannot wait to go back. The service and the food was exceptional! I love the lasagna and all of their appetizers that we tried. This gets more than five stars.
Morgan M via tripadvisor.com - Apr 6, 2018
Wow, well worth your time; excellent!
The Italian House is on Park Street, zoned especially just for neat and nichey restaurants. This is a great place, well worth your consideration. Reservations highly recommended. Menu is centered around an "Italian" view of the world but that sells it short. Really a creative...More ... read more
ralphwilhelm1 via tripadvisor.com - Apr 6, 2018
I recently visited here for a business trip, and I already cannot wait to go back. The service and the food was exceptional! I love the lasagna and all of their appetizers that we tried. This gets more than five stars.
Morgan McClain via google.com - Apr 6, 2018
Love this place.. Awesome atmosphere great food!
Mike Hayden via google.com - Apr 4, 2018
Just went to The Italian House on Park for the first time and LOVED IT! Neat atmosphere and the foo
Just went to The Italian House on Park for the first time and LOVED IT! Neat atmosphere and the food was amazing and our server and hostess were both fantastic, would definitely visit again ���� ... read more
Breanna Cress via facebook.com - Apr 4, 2018
Might be the best Italian in the area
Good food and good service.....attentive but not over-bearing. Had crab cakes.....they are baked versus fried. Very good. The lasagna passed the taste test.....good, cheesy and wonderful sauce. Chicken marsala might be the second best we have had. And, for dessert, try the Tiramisu. They have...More ... read more
gold-vintner via tripadvisor.com - Apr 1, 2018
One of the best restaurants on the North Side. Scallops are great. If you get the lasagna, ask for them to add the alfredo sauce. Back patio is amazing and the few live bands we've heard have all been great. Highly recommend ... read more
Anthony Whitaker via google.com - Apr 1, 2018
Best authentic Italian food in Hamilton County if you ask me! Loved the vibe and the staff too!
Best authentic Italian food in Hamilton County if you ask me! Loved the vibe and the staff too!
Mackenzie Bowman via facebook.com - Mar 24, 2018
Very good! A bit expensive, but flavorful and generous portions.
Douglas McLean via google.com - Mar 22, 2018
GREAT Atmosphere!!!
Adam Collar via google.com - Mar 21, 2018
Came here on St Pattys day with some friends for the first time and it was great from the food to t
Came here on St Pattys day with some friends for the first time and it was great from the food to the service. The calamari starter was very good. Lasagna is the best we've ever had and that is saying something. Highly recommend and we will be back.
Doug Burroughs via facebook.com - Mar 17, 2018
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
  Facebook  Zomato  Trip Advisor